Budget director praises efficacy of reserved health fund

By Ethan Hartley
Posted 2/15/18

By ETHAN HARTLEY -- According to the finance director for Warwick Public Schools, having a restricted fund balance dedicated to controlling the costs of increasing premiums and other healthcare related costs has saved the district millions.

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

Budget director praises efficacy of reserved health fund

Posted

According to Anthony Ferrucci, finance director for Warwick Public Schools, having a restricted fund balance dedicated to controlling the costs of increasing premiums and other healthcare related costs has saved the district millions of dollars in potential healthcare cost increases since 2012.

This fund, sometimes referred to in a disparaging way by critics of the school administration as a “slush fund” that can be dipped into frivolously, is one of 20 such funds set up by municipalities and public school entities – known collaboratively as WB Community Health, which purchases health insurance from Blue Cross for its members at competitive rates, and is based in Warwick.

Ferrucci explained how, in light of Blue Cross announcing this past summer that insurance premiums could rise by as much as 12.1 percent, being a member of the collaborative and having a dedicated fund that can mitigate increases in premiums without requiring special budgetary attention is hugely beneficial to the district, and to the taxpayers.

“In theory, if they’re [Blue Cross] announcing 7 to 10 percent increases every single year and they’re negotiating these contracts, then in the last six years our costs should have gone up between 42 and 60 percent,” Ferrucci said. “Back in 2012 our family plan was $1,310. Our current family plan is $1,670. That’s $360 over the course of six years – about a 25 percent increase over the 6-year cycle. That’s a 4.5 percent increase in premiums, which is about half of what Blue Cross is claiming its costs are…So I think our participation in WB Health is phenomenal in managing our health costs under the current models and access points that we have, and I’m really proud of the results that this organization has done.”

Ferrucci explained how at one time, the fund had a surplus of about $3.3 million, which has stirred some controversy in the past as budgets ran tight, and especially when staffing has been cut to mitigate costs and close budgetary shortfalls.

However he continued to say that the department has used $1.4 million of that surplus over the years to balance premium costs, meaning they aren’t passed onto the employees and taxpayers to such an extreme degree, and the reserve fund now sits around $1.8 million.

“I’d say that puts us in a precarious position,” Ferrucci said when asked by Superintendent Philip Thornton what he thought about the idea of using the fund for other school-related costs. “Because if our plans go up by that 10 percent that they are talking about, then we’ll have to pay that 10 percent back and also increase our premiums on a go-forward basis. Literally, we could be facing a 20 percent hike… We have not had to absorb that kind of cost in our operating budget in the last six years. So it would be foolish in my opinion to raid this particular account.”

School committee chairwoman Beth Furtado also cautioned against using the account for other means besides a safeguard against healthcare costs.

“If we had an employee or two employees with a catastrophic illness, the fact that we have that money sitting would offset the costs of our exposure,” she said.

“Those types of events do happen, and those types of events are what makes the premiums escalate and become budget-burdened,” Ferrucci said, agreeing. “But because we have a surplus on file, we are enabled to be able to build up to those costs over a two or three-year window, and in some cases those costs would stabilize. So we’re able to ride out that storm because of the success of this.”

Ferrucci also mentioned that the fund balance is placed into investments, though he didn’t specify the type of investment, with earnings that are credited to the schools to further help decrease the burden on employees paying into the system.

School committee member David Testa has been an outspoken defender of the healthcare fund, and didn’t change his message on Tuesday night.

“I think six years has proven this is the right thing to do,” he said. “This is good budgeting, plain and simple. If you can’t see that, then you don’t understand budgeting, in my view.”

Comments

3 comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

  • CrickeeRaven

    Hmmm... where have I read someone calling the health care reserve fund "unnecessary?"

    Oh, yeah, in past comments by the failed 2016 candidate who calls himself "mayor": http://warwickonline.com/stories/falling-deeper-and-deeper-down-the-rabbit-hole,131160?#comments

    This is the same person who attacked the school committee during and after the recent contract negotiations -- and yet that same school committee has ensured slower growth in the increase in teacher health care costs by using the reserve fund to buy into a larger health care buying pool.

    The fake "mayor" has accused the school committee of not being accountable -- and yet here is Mr. Ferrucci explaining exactly how the health fund has been used, and what benefit it has provided school staff and taxpayers.

    The fake "mayor" also still has not been accountable for failing to report how he paid for a political advertisement and issuing campaign claims that are objectively and provably false:

    https://warwickpost.com/gop-chair-files-election-board-complaint-against-corrente-for-failing-to-report-ad-hq-spending/

    https://warwickpost.com/digit-spinner-richard-corrente-fudges-numbers/

    It is a certainty that the fake "mayor" will continue to humiliate himself through his uninformed and delusional statements.

    Friday, February 16, 2018 Report this

  • richardcorrente

    I have met with Finance Director of the Warwick Public Schools, Anthony Ferrucci in regards to this matter in December 2017. He respects my view that Warwick does not need this extra cash reserve fund. As health insurance costs increase, so would the premiums, just like they do if you had a personal Blue Cross Policy. I respect his opinion, although I don't agree with it. He feels that Warwick needs the multi-million dollar cash reserve to keep the changes from being too sudden.

    The fact that Warwick has, as of this date $1,800,000 in the fund shows that the taxpayers have paid $1,800,000 that they really didn't need to pay when they did. Have you ever sent a creditor more money than you owed them?

    In essence his plan is for the taxpayers to overpay today just in case we need extra money to cover tomorrows rate increases.

    I say that if we need a dollar from the taxpayers we shouldn't bill them for more today just in case we might need it tomorrow. If Blue Cross ever finds out that Warwick has extra money I can bet they will be raising their rates accordingly. They are not a billion-dollar non-profit agency for nothing.

    I respect Mr. Ferrucci's opinion and I sincerely appreciated the quality time he gave me but I don't agree with his math.

    Sincerely,

    Rick Corrente

    The Taxpayers Mayor

    Friday, February 16, 2018 Report this

  • CrickeeRaven

    As predicted, the fake "mayor" can not help substituting his delusional opinions for proven successful management techniques.

    It is a great consolation that honest, taxpaying voters will overwhelmingly reject his candidacy again this November and ensure that his disproven comments never go any further than this website.

    Friday, February 16, 2018 Report this